Secret’s out: 20 ideas for throwing a surprise birthday party

An illustration of a door opening into a dark room filled with confetti and the words “Surprise party!”
Paperless Post BlogBirthday > Secret’s out: 20 ideas for throwing a surprise birthday party

Want to know a secret? Throwing a successful surprise party is a lot easier than you might think. With just a bit of careful consideration, it can be a memorable occasion any guest of honor will hold dear for the rest of their lives.

That key, of course, is to utilize the element of surprise. So, how to execute a surprise birthday party without showing your hand? In this guide, we’ll talk shop on birthday surprise ideas, teach you how to plan a birthday party, and most importantly,  give you tips on how to keep your pièce de résistance hush-hush until the big reveal.


Plan it all before the big day

The more details you can finesse ahead of time, the better equipped you’ll be to keep your master plan under wraps until the big day.

Let’s dive into the four essentials you’ll want locked and loaded before setting the gears in motion.


left: Cocktails and a mini disco ball. Right: An invitation with “Shhhhh!” written in gold glitter.Image by Cottonbro; “It’s Called a ‘Secret’” by Paperless Post.


Surprise birthday theme ideas

No other element will set the tone of the affair more than your party theme. Not only will it help dictate the location, decor, party supplies, and party agenda, but it’s also a decisive factor in making your guest of honor feel at home (and still on cloud nine!) after the initial fanfare. So, how do you choose from the several birthday celebration ideas out there?

To set an ambiance they’ll appreciate, begin with the following questionnaire:

— How does your guest of honor like to unwind (or turn up) in their own leisure time?

— What types of environments does your guest of honor gravitate towards?

— How does your guest of honor like to socialize? Do they favor small dinners with close friends or night-of-a-lifetime ragers in rooms full of strangers?

— Is your guest of honor a diehard fan of any movies, TV shows, video games, or fantasy novels?

— How much of an investment are you willing to make in specially-themed decor?

— How much time are you and your party planning squad willing to put into setting the stage?

Once you’ve assessed the type of environment and size of the party your guest of honor would thrive in, it’s time to choose a theme that would strike their fancy. If you’re feeling stuck, here are a few tried-and-true party ideas to consider:

#1 Cocktail hour. Whether you’re upping the ante from your friend group’s typical cheap beer and pizza nights, or you know the guest of honor has a thing for complicated mixed drinks, hosting a cocktail hour-themed surprise party with your pal’s favorite spirits is always a top shelf idea. For an extra personal touch, name some of your concoctions after the birthday celebrator.

#2 Roaring ’20s. This one’s especially great for someone in their 20s (or maybe in their last year before 30)—but really, who wouldn’t love being honored with a party as glitzy as Gatsby’s? Stack those coupe glasses, stock up on splashy metallic party supplies, and ask all your guests to dress up in their finest flapper attire. For more Roaring ’20s party ideas, read our complete guide.

#3 Tea party. If the birthday-haver enjoys a proper afternoon with cute little cakes included—or just likes to go a little mad—a surprise tea party is the way to go. Supply all types of tea for your guests to try, and don’t forget some tea-infused cocktails for those who like an adult beverage. Bonus points if you’re able to hold it in a garden. If not, put plenty of flowers on the table. For more decorating tips, visit our blog.

#4 Luau. If your friend or family member is a fan of island vibes (and who isn’t?), treat them to a tropical or luau-themed surprise party. Turn up the heat with a menu of Hawaiian barbecue food and ask guests to wear Hawaiian-style shirts. For more ideas, read our luau party guide.

#5 Southern BBQ. Even if you’re living in Alaska, you can’t go wrong with a Southern Barbecue surprise party. If the party person is a lover of fine, flavorful cooking, put out some gingham tablecloths, fire up the grill (or order catering from a local restaurant), and be sure to provide plenty of napkins.

#6 Pool party. If your guest of honor moonlights as a mermaid (and you happen to have access to a pool), a surprise pool party could be in the cards. Fill the pool up with fun floats, and provide plenty of cold drinks, sunblock, and hydrating ice water. And don’t forget to bring the birthday-haver a swimsuit and towel.

#7 Seasonal party. If you’re still not sure what theme of surprise party to throw, why not take a hint from the weather outside with a seasonal party? From cider tasting in the fall to ice skating in the winter to the first picnic of the year in the spring, sometimes it’s best to let Mother Nature guide your celebration! Add one sentence about why this is a great idea. 

Lastly, remember that certain seasons, weather conditions, or venues may limit how you plan to channel your theme. Nothing is stopping you from throwing a South Carolina barbeque in the middle of February, but if your top priority is to keep guests comfortable, this might mean having your “smoke show” catered rather than firing up the patio grill.


Ideas to help you find the perfect decor

With any birthday surprise, décor is a decisive factor in the mise-en-scene of the occasion. The good news? You don’t have to go to extreme lengths (or extreme costs) to manifest the theme you’re envisioning.

If you’re throwing a blowout affair, consider hiring a planner or recruiting some pals in your squad to help you set the scene. But if you’re planning a slightly more low-key event, try incorporating some of these affordable decoration tips:

#8 Switch up the lighting: Lighting is a powerful game-changer when you’re on a party planning budget. Votive candles are low-cost but have transformative potential to change a humdrum spare room into a palace of ambiance. String lights are a cheap, versatile electric alternative if you’re at all concerned about fire hazards in a crowded room—or making sure the candles don’t burn out before your guest of honor arrives. For ultimate vibes, you can also switch out your usual white light bulbs for color-changing or black light bulbs. 

#9 Use food as décor: If your honored guest is a foodie, their face will light up at the sight of impeccably-plated hors d’oeuvres even more so than seeing a bunch of balloons and banners. To make the whole room feel festive and cohesive, be sure to distribute your expertly arranged nibbles evenly throughout the venue.

#10 Rearrange the furniture: If you’re throwing a party in familiar digs, like a mutual friend’s apartment or your own, make the space feel special by rearranging the furniture for the occasion. A little feng shui can help breathe magic into a space that would feel ordinary otherwise, making room (literally!) for plenty of new, fun memories-in-the-making. 

#11 B.Y.O.D. (Bring Your Own Decor): More often than not, planning a surprise party is a group effort. If you’re on a budget, recruit your pals to loan decorative pieces to make your guest of honor’s birthday special. Whether that’s tchotchkes swiped from their windowsill, samples from their indoor plant menagerie, flowers from their garden, or funky furniture they inherited from their stylish aunt, the more you can pool your resources, the more unique and heartfelt the party landscape will feel. Teamwork makes the dream work, people. 


left: A disco ball hanging from a club ceiling. Right: An invitation shows a door opening into a dark room filled with confetti and the words “Surprise party!”Image by Jesse Echevarria; “Last Door on the Left” by Paperless Post.


Guest list ideas

#12 Invite early. As party director, it’s in your best interest to run a tight ship until the moment your guest of honor walks unwittingly through the front door. That means knowing who your guests are from the get-go, and cautioning all those invited to keep their lips sealed before the big day. You can also send out your online surprise party invitations early with a visible guest list for all those invited to see. Any of these options will discourage any loose-lipped guests from spreading confidential party information beyond the shroud of secrecy.

#11 Organize on the DL. If you’re at all concerned about guests letting the surprise slip ahead of time, consider creating a group chat or email where everyone can see who else is invited.


Left: A red and pink invitation with the letters STFU. Right: A single-layer cake with citrus fruit and sparklers on top.“The Quiet Game” by Paperless Post; Image by Storiès.


Party favors and food

If you think of your party theme, decorations, and guest list as the foundations of your party, then your menu and party favors are what will provide the finishing touches that will make for a truly special occasion.

First, let’s dig into the food. Here’s how to plan a knockout menu:

#12 Rule out allergens. Ask your guests if they have any allergies or dietary restrictions (this is where that group chat comes in handy). Most importantly, don’t forget about your guest of honor. If you’re not sure about any allergies they may have, crowd-source your guest list for intel on what ingredients are off the menu, or casually work it into the conversation. 

#13 Design your menu with a cuisine in mind. If you’re throwing your surprise party at a restaurant or bar, you may have already designed your menu around their offerings (and, hopefully, your guest of honor’s favorite foods). If you’re hosting on the home front, consider having your theme dictate the celebratory eats. Planning an English garden party? Crustless sandwiches and merengues will do. Hosting a Prohibition-inspired soiree? Do a little sleuthing and see what Al Capone’s favorite entrees were in Chicago speakeasies. We hope you like spaghetti.

#14 Make it a potluck. Whether you want to cut costs, save time, or spare your guests from your half-baked kitchen skills, there are many reasons to hold a potluck. In a world where everyone seems to have their own set of dietary limitations, encouraging guests to bring their own dishes adds versatility to your menu while ensuring everyone can dig in together. Just be mindful of the lag time between their arrival and your guest of honor—if you’re worried about food going cold (or melting), put the oven on preheat and clear some space in your fridge before guests arrive.

#15 Birthday cake alternatives. If your guest of honor has insisted in the past that they’re not a fan of birthday cake, get creative—a tower of eclairs, a throwback Jell-O mold, or even a flight of sweet cocktails can close out the meal with something special. Just make sure whatever confection you choose has room for a candle so the birthday lad or lass can make their birthday wish.


How to keep it a secret

Obviously, the best way to keep a secret is to not divulge anything about it. But when it comes to a surprise party, we’ve got other tips to stop you from spilling. Once you’ve prepped, primped, and ironed out every last detail of the planning, it’s time to put on your spy gear and set the event into motion—extra stealth-like.

There are three components of pulling off a surprise party with finesse: setting the location, sending the birthday invitations, and creating the diversion.

#16 Choose an easy location. For surprise birthday parties, always choose a locale that’s on the path of least resistance. For instance, if you’re holding the party on a weeknight, the birthday boy or girl in question (and your guests) may not be up for a trek across town after a long day of work. Furthermore, consider how your guests will be arriving. Guests driving in will need to find parking, and having 20 cars packed into a parking lot may be a dead giveaway if everyone is hunkered down before your guest of honor arrives. Ideally, the location you settle on will make for smooth sailing for everyone—guests and guest of honor, alike.

#17 Communicate where guests should park ahead of time. Consider how your guests will be arriving. Guests driving in will need to find parking, and having 20 cars packed into a parking lot may be a dead giveaway if everyone is hunkered down before your guest of honor arrives. Ideally, the location you settle on will make for smooth sailing for everyone—guests and guest of honor, alike.

#18 Determine the best hiding spots in advance. Ensure your location of choice has places where guests can remain concealed until the exact right moment. Bear in mind that not everyone will enjoy an ambush of faces—however beloved—from behind curtains, couches, and door thresholds. If your guest of honor isn’t an adrenaline junkie, pick a site that’s mildly sequestered, like a gnoll in the park or the cellar room of a favorite restaurant.

#19 Plan the entrance. Some venues have multiple entryways, making it easier for late arrivals to sneak in the back door and still be a part of the fun. If you’re hosting your surprise birthday party in a restaurant, bar, or ballroom, pay them a visit ahead of time and reconnoiter the floor plan to make the most of its surprise potential.

#20 Set up a distraction. Those final moments before the big surprise will have all your guests on the edge of their seats—but your guest of honor shouldn’t suspect a thing when they first stroll into your line of vision. To keep them none the wiser until the time is right, you’ll need a perfect distraction to keep the surprise under wraps.

Depending on how extroverted your guest of honor is, it can be a tall order to rally them for an outing. Try enlisting a close friend (and a surprise party ally) to treat them to a pre-event hangout that can seamlessly transition into the main event. For instance, if your friend is a beer connoisseur, see if a pal is up to take them for a pre-party tasting at a nearby brewery. If you’re hosting your party in a park, maybe they’ll be up for a sunny stroll before walking (unbeknownst to them) into the main event.

No matter how you choose to prime your pal for the big surprise, always put their comfort first. The more relaxed they are before the hoopla, the more they’re sure to cherish it.



How to send out invites (hint: with caution!)

Getting your invitations batched and sent out is one of the most sensitive elements of any party planning initiative, and it gets a lot more complicated when you need to keep them confidential.

Here are some surprise party invitations designed to keep your secret safe, no matter what kind of bash you’ve planned: 


Sweet but stately: Save the event details for the reverse side of the card and spotlight a photo of the guest of honor instead. Aim for invites that make event details like location, assembly time, and the arrival time of your guest less immediately noticeable.


Silent but bold: Sometimes, you don’t need to make a peep to get your message across. Let artwork do the talking for you with a vibrant, stylish graphic that speaks for itself to relate your event’s essence: keep your traps shut, folks. This shindig is strictly confidential. 


Classic and subtle: If you really want to fly under the radar, choose an invite with neutral, camouflage-style colors. Opt for styles with polished graphics that use small, barely-there text to keep the focus on the essentials: where it is, when it’s happening, and when to get there to be in the welcome clique.


As for the text? For surprise parties, keep it simple—and a little sly. Just the key details will do, like so:


Keep it quiet…

it’s a surprise

In honor of

Sugar’s 33rd Birthday

Saturday, March 29th

At 7PM

Society Syncopation

59 Wilder Avenue, Miami


sugar kane arrives at 8!


Here are some more tips for invitations:


— Use a photo card with a funny or sweet picture of the guest of honor. For a milestone birthday, a baby or childhood picture adds in an always-appreciated element of adorability.


— Make sure you send a clear message to your guests by putting the word “SURPRISE” front and center on your invitation. That will help ensure your guests don’t accidentally spill the party beans.


— Provide instructions for guests on how to arrive without alerting the guest of honor. For example, “Please be advised this is a SURPRISE. Do not speak to [Name] about this invitation for any reason. Please arrive at 6:45, [Name] will arrive at 7:00.” 


— Get a fun video birthday gift going by attaching a link for a video message service to the invitation. During the party, everyone can watch the video together—and the guest of honor can get a glimpse at how much planning and excitement went into the surprise party planning. 


An online invitation with a pink table spread of desserts and tapered candles.“Surprise Shindig” Flyer by Paperless Post.

Psst! Pass it on with Paperless Post

Pulling off a surprise birthday celebration takes impeccable planning skills—not to mention the self-restraint you and your guests need to keep the secret. When it comes to getting the word out, your top priority is to send out invitations as seamlessly (and stealthily) as possible. That’s where Paperless Post comes in. 

To send your invitations without a trace—and avoid anyone who shouldn’t see them accidentally sneaking a peek at a paper invite hanging on a refrigerator—your best bet is to keep them digital. Check out Paperless Post’s complete range of on-theme surprise birthday invitations, ideal for slipping into guests’ inboxes without a whisper, keeping guest counts and guest messaging all in one place, and launching a surprise birthday party planning mission they’ll neither suspect—nor forget. 


Browse Surprise Birthday Invitations